top of page

Folding a Helical Pair into a Knot of Light

Writer: Kalle Lintinen
Kalle Lintinen
4 days ago
2 min read

In my last post I presented the basic model of folding a pair of flat helices into a spring of an electromagnetic wave. While I was relatively satisfied with the logic of the folding, after publishing the post, I began feeling uneasy about the idea of how the two helices, the electrical and the magnetic one, overlap. Jos looking at the model it seemed that the overlap was more ‘glued on’ rather than based on an actual mechanism. So, in today’s post, I’m correcting my overlapping hypothesis. Or more specifically my folding hypothesis.

 

The best way to illustrate the mechanism of folding is to show folding in several steps. In practice, I went to blender and made several copies of a helix, with a simple deform/bend modifier applied to it with several angles of bending: specifically, 30°, 90°, 180°, 270° and finally 360°, or the end state. And this is what these folds look like:

From this model, it’s obvious that the unknotted model of my previous post was wrong (or at least much less probable). When folded in this manner, with small angles the two neighboring helices are offset in the up-down direction (z-axis in my Blender model), whereas the offsetting rotates as the angle of rotation increases. Finally, with an angle of folding of 360°, the offset is rotated by 90 degrees (being along the x-axis in my Blender model).

 

This indicates that when in motion, the electric and magnetic components are otherwise identical, but with one component moving in front of the other.

 

However, the first four (incomplete) folds in the model above probably aren’t 100% the way the fold takes place. Rather, the starting point is a double helix that twists around itself once when the folding angle is zero. This way the starting point and the end point are topologically equal, as the final folded spring is a knot. I actually checked this by dragging one of the helices of the pair along the x axis and observed that to detach the loops from each other, one loop would need to pass through its neighbor.

 

So, to make my model complete, I need to be able to illustrate the folding of a knotted loop with intermediate steps. I know I don’t know how to do it in this post, but if I’m able to do it, I’ll be almost 100% certain that my model reflects real-life physics. But on the other hand, if I’m not able to do it, I might need to revise my model. Because I’m highly skeptical of the notion that the helical knot would actually open at any point.


This means that the above model isn't exactly right, but it's a good starting point.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page